Reading expert: free reading isn't the be all and end all

Reading expert: free reading isn't the be all and end all

Play all audios:

Loading...

What Michael L. Kamil, a reading researcher at Stanford University who was a guest on an _EdWeek_ live chat today on adolescent literacy, has to say about free reading may surprise you. A transcript is now available. Here was the question: “What is your opinion of allowing students time in class to read what they want, instead of following a rigid, prescribed reading plan?” Kamil gave the following answer: > The research on free reading, reading practice, or recreational > reading shows that having students read more does NOT lead to better > reading. Instead it seems to show that good readers read a lot more > than poor readers. Besides, the key to learning is not to read > randomly but rather to obtain both organized and useful knowledge. > ... If we believe it is important for students to learn mathematics, > history, biology, etc., we have to direct students to read specific > materials. As a supplement, with appropriate instruction and > feedback, some choice in reading does help, but only with those two > variables added in. Readers, what are your observations about students’ free reading?

What Michael L. Kamil, a reading researcher at Stanford University who was a guest on an _EdWeek_ live chat today on adolescent literacy, has to say about free reading may surprise you. A


transcript is now available. Here was the question: “What is your opinion of allowing students time in class to read what they want, instead of following a rigid, prescribed reading plan?”


Kamil gave the following answer: > The research on free reading, reading practice, or recreational > reading shows that having students read more does NOT lead to better > reading. 


Instead it seems to show that good readers read a lot more > than poor readers. Besides, the key to learning is not to read > randomly but rather to obtain both organized and useful 


knowledge. > ... If we believe it is important for students to learn mathematics, > history, biology, etc., we have to direct students to read specific > materials. As a supplement,


 with appropriate instruction and > feedback, some choice in reading does help, but only with those two > variables added in. Readers, what are your observations about students’ free


reading?