ABSTRACT Societal perceptions of the diagnosis and treatment of cognitive impairment after severe brain injury have been influenced by the legacies of the right-to-die movement and

psychosurgery. Here I propose an ethical stereotaxy for severe brain injury that balances risks, benefits and access to this neglected population, in light of advances in cognitive

neuroscience. Access through your institution Buy or subscribe This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution ACCESS OPTIONS Access through your institution Subscribe

to this journal Receive 12 print issues and online access $189.00 per year only $15.75 per issue Learn more Buy this article * Purchase on SpringerLink * Instant access to full article PDF

N. D. Persistent vegetative state: a site map of the debate. In _HMS Beagle: The BioMedNet Magazine_ (18 February, 2000) Issue 72 (http://news.bmn.com/hmsbeagle/76/viewpts/overview). Google

Scholar  * Bullinger, M. et al. Quality of life in patients with traumatic brain injury — basic issues, assessment and recommendations. _Restor. Neurol. Neurosci._ 20, 111–124 (2002). CAS 

PubMed  Google Scholar  * Phipps, E. & Whyte, J. Medical decision-making with persons who are minimally conscious. _Am. J. Phys. Med. Rehabil._ 78, 77–82 (1999). Article  CAS  Google

Scholar  * Phipps, E., DiPasquale, M., Blitz, C. L. & Whyte, J. Interpreting responsiveness in persons with severe traumatic brain injury: beliefs in families and quantitative

evaluations. _J. Head Trauma Rehabil._ 12, 52–69 (1997). Article  Google Scholar  * Fins, J. J. A proposed ethical framework for interventional cognitive neuroscience: a consideration of

deep brain stimulation in impaired consciousness. _Neurol. Res._ 22, 273–278 (2000). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Consensus conference. Rehabilitation of persons with traumatic brain

injury. NIH Consensus Development Panel on Rehabilitation of Persons with Traumatic Brain Injury. _J. Am. Med. Assoc._ 282, 974–983 (1999). * Cantor, N. L. Twenty-five years after Quinlan: a

review of the jurisprudence of death and dying. _J. Law Med. Ethics_ 29, 182–196 (2001). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Cranford, R. E. Medical futility: transforming a clinical concept

into legal and social policies. _J. Am. Geriatr. Soc._ 42, 894–898 (1994). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Annas, G. J. The 'right to die' in America: sloganeering from Quinlan and

Cruzan to Quill and Kevorkian. _Duquesne Law Rev._ 34, 875–897 (1996). PubMed  Google Scholar  * Landmark article August 5, 1968: a definition of irreversible coma. Report of the ad hoc

committee of the Harvard Medical School to examine the definition of brain death. _J. Am. Med. Assoc._ 205, 337–340 (1968). * Stevens, M. L. Redefining death in America, 1968. _Caduceus_ 11,

207–219 (1995). CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar  * Beecher, H. K. Ethical problems created by the hopelessly unconscious patient. _N. Engl. J. Med._ 278, 1425–1430 (1968). Article  CAS  Google

Scholar  * Jennett, B. & Plum, F. Persistent vegetative state after brain damage. A syndrome in search of a name. _Lancet_ 1, 734–737 (1972). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Jennett, B.

_The Vegetative State_ (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK, 2002). Book  Google Scholar  * Bernat, J. L. A defense of the whole-brain concept of death. _Hastings Cent. Rep._ 28 (2), 14–23

(1998). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Giacino, J. T. et al. The minimally conscious state: definition and diagnostic criteria. _Neurology_ 58, 349–353 (2002). Article  Google Scholar  *

Jennett, B., Adams, J. H., Murray, L. S. & Graham, D. I. Neuropathology in vegetative and severely disabled patients after head injury. _Neurology_ 56, 486–490 (2001). Article  CAS 

Google Scholar  * Schiff, N. D. et al. Residual cerebral activity and behavioural fragments can remain in the persistently vegetative brain. _Brain_ 125, 1210–1234 (2002). Article  Google

Scholar  * Menon, D. K. et al. Cortical processing in persistent vegetative state. Wolfson Brain Imaging Centre Team. _Lancet_ 352, 200 (1998). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Wilson, B. A.,

Gracey, F. & Bainbridge, K. Cognitive recovery form 'persistent vegetative state': psychological and personal perspectives. _Brain Inj._ 15, 1083–1092 (2001). Article  CAS 

Google Scholar  * Schiff, N. D. & Plum, F. Cortical function in the persistent vegetative state. _Trends Cogn. Sci._ 3, 43–44 (1999). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * van Domburg, P. H.,

ten Donkelaar, H. J. & Notermans, S. Akinetic mutism with bithalamic infarction. Neurophysiological correlates. _J. Neurol. Sci._ 139, 58–65 (1996). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  *

Kampfl, A. et al. Prediction of recovery from post-traumatic vegetative state with cerebral magnetic-resonance imaging. _Lancet_ 351, 1763–1767 (1998). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  *

Laureys, S., Faymonville, M. E., Moonen, G., Luxen, A. & Maquet, P. PET scanning and neuronal loss in acute vegetative state. _Lancet_ 355, 1825–1826 (2000). Article  CAS  Google Scholar

  * Laureys, S. et al. Brain function in the vegetative state. _Acta Neurol. (Belg.)_ 102, 177–185 (2002). Google Scholar  * Hirsch, J. et al. fMRI reveals intact cognitive systems in

minimally conscious patients. _Soc. Neurosci. Abstr._ 27, 529.14 (2001). Google Scholar  * Strauss, D. J., Ashwal, S., Day, S. M. & Shavelle, R. M. Life expectancy of children in

vegetative and minimally conscious states. _Pediatr. Neurol._ 23, 312–319 (2000). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Callahan, D. Necessity, futility and the good society. _J. Am. Geriatr.

Soc._ 42, 866–867 (1994). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Zarkovich, E. & Upshur, R. E. The virtues of evidence. _Theor. Med. Bioeth._ 23, 403–412 (2002). Article  Google Scholar  *

Giacino, J. T. et al. Development of practice guidelines for assessment and management of the vegetative and minimally conscious states. _J. Head Trauma Rehabil._ 12, 79–89 (1997). Article 

Google Scholar  * Cranford, R. E. The vegetative and minimally conscious states: ethical implications. _Geriatrics_ 53, S70–S73 (1998). PubMed  Google Scholar  * Shewmon, D. A. The minimally

conscious state: definition and diagnostic criteria. _Neurology_ 58, 506–507 (2002). Article  Google Scholar  * Payne, K., Taylor, R. M., Stocking, C. & Sachs, G. A. Physicians'

attitudes about the care of patients in the persistent vegetative state: a national survey. _Ann. Intern. Med._ 125, 104–110 (1996). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Coleman, D. The minimally

conscious state: definition and diagnostic criteria. _Neurology_ 58, 506–507 (2002). Article  Google Scholar  * Cicerone, K. D. et al. Evidence-based cognitive rehabilitation:

recommendations for clinical practice. _Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil._ 81, 1596–1615 (2000). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Schiff, N. D. & Pulver, M. Does vestibular stimulation activate

thalamocortical mechanisms that reintegrate impaired cortical regions? _Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B_ 266, 421–423 (1999). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Schiff, N. D., Plum, F. & Rezai, A. R.

Developing prosthetics to treat cognitive disabilities resulting from acquired brain injuries. _Neurol. Res._ 24, 116–124 (2002). Article  Google Scholar  * Schiff, N. D. & Purpura, K.

P. Towards a neurophysiologic foundation for cognitive neuromodulation through deep brain stimulation. _Thal. Rel. Syst._ 2, 55–69 (2002). Article  Google Scholar  * Tsubokawa, T. &

Yamamoto, T. in _Textbook of Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery_ (eds Gildenberg, P. L. & Tasker, R. R.) 1979–1986 (McGraw-Hill Professional, New York, 1998). Google Scholar  *

Schneiderman, L. J., Jecker, N. S. & Jonsen, A. R. Medical futility: its meaning and ethical implications. _Ann. Intern. Med._ 112, 949–954 (1990). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  *

Schneiderman, L. J. The futility debate: effective versus beneficial intervention. _J. Am. Geriatr. Soc._ 42, 883–886 (1994). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Smothers, R. Injured in

'88, Officer awakes in '96. _New York Times_ (New York, February 16, 1995). * Burruss, J. W. & Chacko, R. C. Episodically remitting akinetic mutism following subarachnoid

hemorrhage. _J. Neuropsychiatry Clin. Neurosci._ 11, 100–102 (1999). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Speelman, J. D. & Bosch, D. A. Resurgence of functional neurosurgery for

Parkinson's disease: a historical perspective. _Mov. Disord._ 13, 582–588 (1998). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Deep-brain stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus or the pars interna

of the globus pallidus in Parkinson's disease. _N. Engl. J. Med._ 345, 956–963 (2001). * Kumar, R. et al. Double-blind evaluation of subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation in

advanced Parkinson's disease. _Neurology_ 51, 850–855 (1998). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Young, R. F. Brain stimulation. _Neurosurg. Clin. N. Am._ 1, 865–879 (1990). Article  CAS 

Google Scholar  * Kopell, B. H. & Rezai, A. The continuing evolution of psychiatric neurosurgery. _CNS Spectrums_ 5 (10), 20–31 (2000). Article  Google Scholar  * Roth, R. M., Flashman,

L. A., Saykin, A. J. & Roberts, D. W. Deep brain stimulation in neuropsychiatric disorders. _Curr. Psychiatry Rep._ 3, 366–372 (2001). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Rapoport, J. L.

& Inoff-Germain, G. Medical and surgical treatment of obsessive–compulsive disorder. _Neurol. Clin._ 15, 421–428 (1997). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Greenberg, B. D. Update on deep

brain stimulation. _J. ECT_ 18, 193–196 (2002). Article  Google Scholar  * Fins, J. J. From psychosurgery to neuromodulation and palliation: history's lessons for the ethical conduct

and regulation of neuropsychiatric research. _Neurosurg. Clin. N. Am._ (in the press). * Delgado, J. M. & Anshen, R. N. (eds) _Physical Control of the Mind: Toward a Psychocivilized

Society_ (Harper and Row, New York, 1969). Google Scholar  * Gaylin, W. M., Meister, J. S. & Neville, R. C. (eds) _Operating on the Mind: The Psychosurgery Conflict_ (Basic Books, New

York, 1975). Google Scholar  * Valenstein, E. S. _Great and Desperate Cures: The Rise and Decline of Psychosurgery and Other Radical Treatments for Mental Illness_ (Basic Books, New York,

1986). Google Scholar  * Editorial. The future of mind control. _The Economist_ (London, May 25, 2002). * Safire, W. The but-what-if factor. _The New York Times_ (New York) A25 (May 16,

2002). * El-Hai, J. The lobotomist. _The Washington Post Magazine_ (Washington) 16–31 (February 4, 2001). * Herbert, W. Psychosurgery redux. _US News & World Report_ (Washington) 63

(November 3, 1997). * Carmichael, M. Healthy shocks to the head. _Newsweek_ (Washington) 56–58 (June 24, 2002) * Fins, J. J. The ethical limits of neuroscience. _Lancet Neurol._ 1, 213

(2002). Article  Google Scholar  * The National Research Act. Public Law 93-348 (July 12, 1974) (http://www.fas.harvard.edu/∼research/PL93-348.html). * The National Commission for the

Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Use of psychosurgery in practice and research: report and recommendations of The National Commission for the Protection of

Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. _Fed. Regist._ 42, 26318–26332 (1977). * Mathew, S. J., Yudofsky, S. C., McCullough, L. B., Teasdale, T. A. & Jankovic, J.

Attitudes toward neurosurgical procedures for Parkinson's disease and obsessive–compulsive disorder. _J. Neuropsychiatry Clin. Neurosci._ 11, 259–267 (1999). Article  CAS  Google

Scholar  * Donnelly, J. The incidence of psychosurgery in the United States, 1971–1973. _Am. J. Psychiatry_ 135, 1476–1480 (1978). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Blatte, H. State prisons

and the use of behavior control. _Hastings Cent. Rep._ 4 (4), 11 (1974). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Culliton, B. J. Psychosurgery: National Commission issues suprisingly favorable

report. _Science_ 194, 299–301 (1976). Article  Google Scholar  * National Bioethics Advisory Commission. _Research Involving Persons With Mental Disorders That May Affect Decisionmaking

Capacity_ (Rockville, Maryland, December 1998) (http://www.georgetown.edu/research/nrcbl/nbac/capacity/TOC.htm). * Michels, R. Are research ethics bad for our mental health? _N. Engl. J.

Med._ 340, 1427–1430 (1999). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Oldham, J. M., Haimowitz, S. & Delano, S. Protection of persons with mental disorders from research risk. _Arch. Gen.

Psychiatry_ 56, 688–693 (1999). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Miller, F. G. & Fins, J. J. Protecting vulnerable research subjects without unduly constraining neuropsychiatric research.

_Arch. Gen. Psychiatry_ 56, 701–702 (1999). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Vanderpool, H. Y. & Weiss, G. B. False data and the therapeutic misconception. _Hastings Cent. Rep._ 17 (2),

16–19 (1987). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Fins, J. J. & Schiff, N. D. Diagnosis and treatment of traumatic brain injury. _J. Am. Med. Assoc._ 283, 2392 (2000). Article  CAS  Google

Scholar  * Cohadon, F., Richer, E., Bougiera, A., Deliack, P. & Loiseau, H. in _Neurostimulation: an Overview_ (eds Lazrthesy, Y. & Upton, A. R. M.) 247–250 (Futura Publishing, Mount

Kisco, New York, 1985). Google Scholar  * Osborn, C. L. _Over my Head_ (Andrews McNeal Publishing, Kansas City, Kansas, 1998). Google Scholar  * Beecher, H. K. After the 'definition of

irreversible coma'. _N. Engl. J. Med._ 281, 1070–1071 (1969). Article  CAS  Google Scholar  Download references ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I thank N. D. Schiff for his close reading and helpful

comments, as well as A. Hudson and E. Kobylarz. An earlier version of this paper was presented as the 2002 Sheldon Berrol Memorial Chautauqua of the American Congress of Rehabilitation

Medicine and American Society of Neurorehabilitation. J.J.F. is an unfunded co-investigator on a planning grant from the National Institute of Health for neuromodulation in patients in the

MCS. AUTHOR INFORMATION AUTHORS AND AFFILIATIONS * the Weill Medical College of Cornell University and the Hastings Center, 525 East 68th Street, F-173, New York, 10021, New York, USA Joseph

J. Fins Authors * Joseph J. Fins View author publications You can also search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar RELATED LINKS RELATED LINKS FURTHER INFORMATION Report and

Recommendations of the National Bioethics Advisory Commission The National Research Act. Public Law 93-348 RIGHTS AND PERMISSIONS Reprints and permissions ABOUT THIS ARTICLE CITE THIS

ARTICLE Fins, J. Constructing an ethical stereotaxy for severe brain injury: balancing risks, benefits and access. _Nat Rev Neurosci_ 4, 323–327 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn1079

Download citation * Issue Date: 01 April 2003 * DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn1079 SHARE THIS ARTICLE Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content: Get

shareable link Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article. Copy to clipboard Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative